Реферат на тему Active Euthenasia

A Kantian Perspective Essay, Research Paper

Euthanasia is one of societys more widely,

and hotly debated moral issues of our time. More directly, active euthanasia,

which by definition, is; Doing something, such as administering a lethal

drug, or using other means that cause a persons death.1 Passive euthanasia,

defined as; Stopping (or not starting) some treatment, which allows a

person to die, the persons condition causes his or her death,2 seems

not to be as debated, perhaps not as recognized, as its counterpart. I

have chosen to look more closely at the issue of active euthanasia, and

whether or not it would be considered ethical, by Kantian standards.

Those who support the practice of active

euthanasia might argue that helping the terminally ill to bring about their

own deaths, allowing them to determine the how and when, is not only humane,

but also allows the person, who is simply living to die, to maintain

dignity by orchestrating their own end, thus letting them die at peace,

rather than suffer to the end, preceiving themselves to be a burden and/or

disgrace, to those they love. According to recent polls, many Canadians

would agree,3 but the question is, have they taken a close look at the

ethical debate? Those who are against active euthanasia would say not,

and would argue that by participating in the practice of active euthanasia,

one is playing God, or perhaps, even worse, that they are not acting

out of mercy, but rather out of selfishness, attempting to lessen their

own burden, and that theore, the act is nothing less than cold-blooded

murder. Murder is defined as; The unlawful, premeditated killing of one

human being by another.4 Euthanasia, in Canada, remains unlawful as of

today, and the act of euthanasia is premeditated, thus whether for the

purpose of mercy or not, euthanasia is, by definition, murder. According

to Kantian perspective and the Holy Bible, murder is both a sin and a crime,

theore we ought not participate in the practice of euthanasia, because

it is murder, and it is the wrong thing to do.

The euthanasia debate raises many questions.

Questions such as; For whose benefit is the murder actually taking place?

Ought we allow family members to make a life-or-death decision on behalf

of a loved one who may never have expressed a desire to die, simply because

they could not vocalize a will to live? (As was the case of Robert Latimer).

If a person should be suffering with an illness of which there seems no

hope of recovery, yet they are unable to make a choice for themselves how

do we know what that person would voluntarily choose? Is it our right to

decide whether or not they have a desire to live? If we ourselves are not

in the position of the individual whose life and/or death is being decided,

we cannot possibly know or understand what their will is, what they would

opt for personally, or even whether or not they can comprehend what is

happening, thus the decisions we are making find us playing God, and

assuming that our decisions are always in the best intrests of another.

Without knowing for sure what the individual would have chosen, we may

well have gone against their will, and thus have committed murder.

Some would argue that the practice of euthanasia

is used as a last resort, when the individual can no longer manage the

pain of their illness. However, that arguement can be rebutted by an observation

made by a proponent of a movement similar to Right to Die. Dr Pieter Admiraal,

a leader of a movement to legalize assisted suicide in the Netherlands,

stated pubicly that pain is never justification for euthanasia considering

the advanced medical techniques currently available to manage pain in almost

every circumstance.5 Thus the pain does not justify death, but rather it

justifies the need for more money to educate health care professionals

on better pain management techniques.

Ought we not look into a suicidal persons

emotional and psychological background before we conclude that his or her

suicide is accep because they are going to die anyway? We ought to

take into consideration, the statistics which tell us that fewer than one

in four people with terminal illness have a desire to die, and that all

of those who did wish to die had previously suffered with clinically diagnosable

depression.6 If we choose to overlook these statistics, and others that

tell us that psychotheraputic treatments are not only available, but equally

successful among people with terminal illness, as among people without7

then we are indeed cutting that persons life short, and thus one again,

commiting murder.

If a physically healthy person who suffered

with depression were to approach us with thoughts of suicide, we would

comfort them, seek treatment for them, and provide as much as we were able,

to see that they got the reassurance and the psychological and/or emotional

help that they needed. Certainly we would not tell them that the choice

was theirs and hand them a gun. Why then do we not do the same for those

suffering with a physical illness? Further statistics tell us that the

chances for living a happy life are often greater for a person who has

attempted suicide, but are stopped, and provided with the help they need,

than for individuals suffering with similar problems, who have never attempted

suicide.8 It would serve us well to take notice of these statistics. We

ought to be making every effort to find alternatives to euthanasia, and

help people with theire problems, instead of helping them to end what very

well could be a happy life.

One must also ask why some doctors would

fight so vigorously to leagalize the practice of killing the terminally

ill, while others maintain that there are many alternatives available that

may offer a satisfactory and comfor quality of life for those suffering

from severe illness. Is it possible that some doctors are selling death

for reasons other than compassion? If the possibility exists for this to

be the case, than we ought to expect some doctors to abuse the system,

as well as the rights and best intrests of the patient, in order to better

themselves financially, or otherwise.

I personally believe that it would be extremely

difficult, perhaps impossible, to legislate a point of illness or disability

where euthanasia would be considered legally or ethically accep. To

do so would be saying that all disabled or terminally ill patients have

no chance for a happy and fulfilling life. I believe that we are taking

quite a risk when we bring about another persons death wilfully, thus

assuming that we have the ability to look into the future and deem their

life unlivable.

Footnotes

1. Barbara MacKinnon, Euthanasia, Ethics

Theory and Contemporary Issues, second edition, p.126, 1998

2. Barbara MacKinnon, Euthanasia, Ethics

Theory and Contemporary Issues, second edition, p.126, 1998

3. TTI Market Explorers, Poll of 603 Adults

in British Colombia, Euthanasia Prevention Coalition, 1997

4. Clarendon Press, Concise Oxford Dictionary,

p. 895, 1995

5. Pieter Admiraal, Euthanasia in the

Netherlands A Dutch Doctors Perspective, (speech presented at the national

convention of the Hemlock Society, Arlington VA, 1986

6. Brown, Henteleff, Barakat and Rowe,

Is It Normal for Terminally Ill Patients to Desire Death?, American Journal

of Psychiatry, Vol. 143, No. 2, 1986

7. Flora Johnson Skelly, Dont Miss Depression,

Physicians say, American Medical News, p. 28, 1992

8. Dahlgren, Suicide and Life Threatening

Behaviour, (Stengel, supra note 4, p. 113), Attempted Suicides 35 Years

Afterward, 1977

Похожие рефераты:

Реферат на тему Euthenasia Essay Research Paper EuthanasiaImmoral or Human Реферат на тему Euthenasia In Australia Essay Research Paper Euthenasia Реферат на тему The Morality Of Euthenasia Essay Research Paper Реферат на тему Passive Smoking Essay Research Paper What is Реферат на тему Smoking Should Be Banned In Public Places Реферат на тему Smoking Essay Research Paper Smoking Smoking is Реферат на тему Smoking Essay Research Paper Smoking What Реферат на тему Smoking Essay Research Paper My research paper Реферат на тему Smoking Essay Research Paper SMOKINGOUTLINEThesis Smoking causes Реферат на тему Creative Story Реферат на тему Creative Story Positraction Essay Research Paper Creative Реферат на тему Creative Story Lycanthrope Essay Research Paper Creative Реферат на тему Creative Story Bathtub Essay Research Paper Creative Реферат на тему Creative Story Grandpa Essay Research Paper Creative Реферат на тему Creative Story Intellegence Essay Research Paper Creative Реферат на тему Teen Suicide Essay Research Paper Teen SuicideThe Реферат на тему Teen Suicide Essay Research Paper The purpose Реферат на тему Reading Vs Television Essay Research Paper Do Реферат на тему Tv Violence Реферат на тему Children And TV Essay Research Paper Children Реферат на тему Television And Its Affects On Children Essay Реферат на тему Violance On Television Cause Aggressive Behavior Essay Реферат на тему Censorship Essay Research Paper While most people Реферат на тему Is Television Good For Children Essay Research Реферат на тему Violence 2 Essay Research Paper Violence By Реферат на тему Violence Makes Violence Essay Research Paper Violence Реферат на тему Violence Essay Research Paper Violence Mentioning Реферат на тему Media Violence Essay Research Paper Media Violence Реферат на тему Domestic Violence Essay Research Paper Domestic ViolenceDomestic Реферат на тему Youth Violence Essay Research Paper Violence is Реферат на тему Origin Of Man Essay Research Paper Реферат на тему Evolution Essay Research Paper Evolution vs CreationEvolution Реферат на тему Spring Tides Essay Research Paper The tides Реферат на тему Lunar Eclipse Lab Essay Research Paper Title Реферат на тему The Greatest Day Essay Research Paper Buzz Реферат на тему Red Tides Essay Research Paper Red tides Реферат на тему Turning Of The Tides Essay Research Paper Реферат на тему The Butterfly Revolution Essay Research Paper After Реферат на тему An Analysis Of White Butterfly Essay Research Реферат на тему Lord Of Fliez Essay Research Paper The Реферат на тему Water Essay Research Paper Water Реферат на тему Was The Moon Landing A Fake Essay Реферат на тему Review Gaveston By Stephanie Merritt Essay Research Реферат на тему Judges Essay Research Paper Qualifications for judges Реферат на тему Tevya And His First Daughter Essay Research Реферат на тему The Daughter Of Time By Josephine Tey Реферат на тему Rappaccinis Daughter Essay Research Paper In Реферат на тему Horse Dealer Daughter Essay Research Paper The Реферат на тему Describing Biblical Parallels In Реферат на тему Mother Daughter Relationship Essay Research Paper The Реферат на тему The Mother-Daughter Relationship In Реферат на тему The Book Of Judges Essay Research Paper Реферат на тему The Notorious Wife Of Bath Essay Research Реферат на тему Eva Luna And A Dolls House The Реферат на тему Eva Duarte De Peron Essay Research Paper Реферат на тему Economic Value Added Essay Research Paper EVA Реферат на тему Eva Peron Essay Research Paper To Lead Реферат на тему Eva Peron Essay Research Paper Mi MensajeBy Реферат на тему Who Is Responsible For The Death Of Реферат на тему Romeo And Juliet Vs West Side Story Реферат на тему Contrast Of Romeo And Juliet An West Реферат на тему COMPARISON OF WEST SIDE STORY AND ROMEO Реферат на тему Romeo And Juliet Versus West Side Story Реферат на тему Romeo And Juliet And West Side Story Реферат на тему Greed Essay Research Paper Greedy Greed Greed Реферат на тему Greed Essay Research Paper Greed can drive Реферат на тему Greed And Fear Essay Research Paper In Реферат на тему The Crucible Evil And Greed In Man Реферат на тему Sports World Should Be Drug Free Essay Реферат на тему Drug Testing 2 Essay Research Paper Should Реферат на тему Argument On Drug Testing Essay Research Paper Реферат на тему Drug Abuse Essay Research Paper DRUG ABUSEPsychology Реферат на тему Student Athletes Deserve More Than Scholarships Essay Реферат на тему Frankenstein S Monster Revisited Essay Research Paper Реферат на тему Achiles Anoptheis Achilles Revisited Essay Research Paper Реферат на тему Babylon Revisited Essay Research Paper An Analysis Реферат на тему Mesomorphosis Revisited Essay Research Paper Metamorphosis RevisitedDespite Реферат на тему In Another Country And Babylon Revisited Masterpieces Реферат на тему Charles Dickens Essay Research Paper CHARLES DICKENSLauren Реферат на тему Charles Dickens Essay Research Paper The Use Реферат на тему Charles Dickins Essay Research Paper CHARLES DICKENS Реферат на тему How Charles Dickens Реферат на тему Charles Dickens Essay Research Paper Charles DickensNo Реферат на тему Huck Finn Essay Research Paper Moral Development Реферат на тему Moral Development Of Huckleberry Finn Essay Research Реферат на тему Huckleberry Реферат на тему Huck Finn Essay Research Paper Including Huckleberry Реферат на тему Huckleberry Finn Essay Research Paper The Life Реферат на тему Biography Of Charles Dickens Essay Research Paper Реферат на тему Charles Dickens 2 Essay Research Paper An Реферат на тему Transcendentalism In Thoreau Essay Research Paper Transcendentalism Реферат на тему Thoreau On Transcendentalism Essay Research Paper The Реферат на тему American Transcendentalism Essay Research Paper TranscendentalismHenry David Реферат на тему Transcendentalism Essay Research Paper Transcendentalism was an Реферат на тему Transcendentalism Essay Research Paper Transcendentalism is a Реферат на тему Thoreau Essay Research Paper Aubrey GeyerModern LiteratureBlock Реферат на тему Transcendentalism 2 Essay Research Paper Although the Реферат на тему Was There Ever Essay Research Paper Transcendentalism Реферат на тему Fighting The War Of Words Essay Research Реферат на тему A Time For Words To Die Essay